ArborDay.org Review: 

Arborday's total rating went up 1 point and their grade stayed at a C. Keep in mind we are rating and reviewing the online store for Arborday located at https://shop.arborday.org/

Arborday continues to be a low price leader with most of their evergreen trees. We found prices starting at $3.78.  Keep in mind that Arbor Day also sends some very small bare root plants.  Many of the evergreen trees we looked at were listed at shipping with a height range of 3 to 12 inches. If you're willing to wait a long time to see results and want evergreen trees & shrubs cheap, this is your place.  

Arborday has been testing and making some cosmetic updates to their online store the past few months.  From what we can tell, they have rolled out these changes to more of their online store. It definitely looks better and seems easier to navigate. 

One of the new changes includes a section on every product to place a review. For the first time, we found an Arborday product review. Just the one product and it had 2 reviews but hopefully a step in the right direction. They also seem to offer both potted and bare root on many of their plants. More potted then we have ever noticed before.

Arborday.org also has a video on many of the product pages showing how to plant bare root trees.  It's actually pretty good with step-by-step directions.

Arborday is located in Nebraska. It's hard to imagine them shipping anything in the middle of winter. So, are they taking your order & money but shipping in spring? It appears that way. The products have a banner that says; "Guaranteed Healthy Delivery". It's not obvious but you can mouse over the banner & click on it to get a popup that elaborates; "When you order trees from The Arbor Day Foundation, your order is guaranteed to arrive in a good, healthy condition or we’ll replace them at no charge. Your trees will be shipped at a suitable time for planting. Each tree and plant is guaranteed to grow, or we’ll replace it within one year of shipment."

The number of evergreen trees and shrubs they have in-stock is impressive, especially for being winter.  53 evergreen trees were for sale when we checked on December 31st.

Arborday, still offers free shipping on orders over $60 which seems to be an on-going promotion with no end date announced. If they're shipping a lot of bare root, it makes sense to offer free shipping. It costs a lot less to ship plants with no dirt. We could not find shipping rates anywhere.  Just by pure trial & error we discovered that $9.95 seems to be a flat rate ship cost with any order under $60. Over $60 automatically gets free shipping.

Arbor Day website goes back to 1995.  They scored highest on both domain authority & years the site has been active out of the 20 sites we evaluated. Their domain authority has taken a hit in recent months, they still have the highest domain authority but their lead has shrunk.

Planting  deciduous bare root trees & shrubs is a little more forgiving since they are dormant.   We found a few sources for planting bare root evergreen shrubs that recommended clipping off most of the foliage prior to transplanting. While it sounds harsh, removing the green foliage will help it survive. It will focus on root growth, crucial for long term success. Just understand if you;re buying a slow growing bareroot evergreen tree or shrub, you will be waiting a while to see results.

What were the red flags?  

• Pretty much the same thing we raised a red flag for in the past. Return Policy.  They may have one but we looked pretty hard and still can’t find one. They do have a new popup promoting a plant guarantee but it doesn't give too many details.
• They now seem to allow product reviews but we could only find a few. There's probably a reason why there aren't many product reviews and I can't of any that would be a positive. It's also next to impossible to find any online reviews for the Arborday store.